Allowing pets in your Merritt Island rental property can increase your pool of potential tenants, but it can also bring extra risks, such as property damage. Finding a balance that protects your property while keeping renters happy can make all the difference.
It's worth noting that Florida ranks 34th in the United States for pet ownership, according to Florida Animal Friend. Merritt Island, in particular, is known for its relaxed lifestyle and family-friendly neighborhoods, which make it a popular choice for pet owners.
Read on to learn more about allowing pets in a rental property.
Are There Any Benefits of Allowing Pets in a Rental Property?
Many landlords are realizing the benefits of pet-friendly rentals. In Merritt Island, many residents consider pets part of the family, so properties that welcome animals attract more interest.
Pet-friendly properties often rent faster because there's less competition. Families and professionals with pets are willing to pay higher rent, sometimes even an extra pet deposit or a monthly pet fee. It can boost your rental income and reduce vacancy rates.
Tenants with pets also tend to stay longer. Moving can be stressful for pet owners, especially when it's hard to find another home that allows animals. Longer leases mean more stable income and fewer turnover costs for landlords.
Allowing pets also helps create a sense of community. In many cases, tenants with pets are more social and responsible. They enjoy doing the following:
- Walking dogs
- Chatting with neighbors
- Maintaining good relationships
Such behavior can help improve the general atmosphere of your property.
If you decide to allow pets, make sure to set clear rules. That's where pet policy advice from a local expert becomes helpful.
What Are the Risks of Allowing Pets in Your Rental Property?
While pets bring many benefits, there are also challenges. The risks of allowing pets mainly involve property damage and potential disturbances.
Some pets may do the following:
- Scratch floors
- Chew furniture
- Stain carpets
Even with careful tenants, accidents can happen. You may also face noise complaints from neighbors if a dog barks frequently. In multi-unit properties, allergies or fears of animals can become issues between tenants.
There's also the risk of liability. If a pet bites a visitor or causes injury, questions about responsibility can crop up. That's why it's important to understand Merritt Island pet laws, which follow Florida's state guidelines on animal control, leash rules, and dangerous breeds.
To manage these risks, consider collecting a refundable pet deposit and charging a small monthly pet rent. You can also require renters to have pet insurance or include pet-related clauses in your lease.
Working with a team of rental property management pros like Bluefin Property Management can help minimize these risks. They can do the following:
- Screen tenants and pets
- Enforce pet agreements
- Ensure your property stays in great condition
How Can You Create a Fair Pet Policy?
A clear and fair pet policy helps balance flexibility with protection. Start by deciding which pets you'll allow. Many landlords permit cats and small to medium-sized dogs, while others also welcome birds, fish, or rabbits.
Next, set limits on the number of pets per unit and any breed or weight restrictions. Such limits should follow all relevant Merritt Island pet laws and fair housing regulations.
Your pet policy should include expectations for cleanliness, noise control, and supervision. For instance, require that dogs be kept on a leash in shared areas and that tenants promptly clean up after their pets.
If you're unsure where to start, Bluefin Property Management can provide pet policy advice tailored to your property type. They understand the benefits of pet-friendly rentals and know how to minimize the risks.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Do I Protect My Property If I Allow Pets?
You can protect your property by including pet clauses in your lease, collecting a pet deposit, and conducting regular inspections. Requiring renters to carry insurance that covers pet-related damages can also help. Partnering with a property manager like Bluefin ensures these protections are enforced properly.
Can I Charge Extra Rent for Pets in Merritt Island?
Yes. Florida law allows landlords to charge a pet deposit or monthly pet rent, as long as it's reasonable and clearly stated in the lease. Many Merritt Island landlords use this extra rent to cover cleaning or potential wear caused by pets.
What's the Difference Between Service Animals and Pets?
Service animals perform precise tasks for people with disabilities, while pets are companions. Landlords must allow service animals even in properties that normally prohibit pets. Emotional support animals are also protected in most cases.
How Can a Property Management Company Help With Pet Policies?
A rental property management company like Bluefin can handle tenant screening, verify pet information, manage deposits, and enforce your pet policy. They can also ensure compliance with housing laws and local ordinances, reducing your workload and stress.
What Happens If a Pet Damages My Property?
If you collect a pet deposit or charge pet rent, those funds can be used to repair damage. If costs exceed the deposit, you can withhold funds from the tenant's security deposit.
Should I Allow Cats But Not Dogs?
That's up to you. Some landlords find cats less destructive, while others prefer dogs because they can be easier to monitor. The best choice depends on your:
- Property type
- Neighborhood
- Comfort level
A property management expert can help evaluate which option makes sense for you.
Having Pets in a Rental Property Can Be a Wise Business Decision
Allowing pets in a rental property has its fair share of rewards and responsibilities.
By teaming up with Bluefin Property Management, you can enjoy amazing benefits while keeping your property secure. From pet policy advice to thorough rental property management, their team ensures that both you and your tenants have a positive experience. Clients especially love the 24/7 online portal for invoices, inspection notes, and much more.
Do you want someone who knows the ins and outs of managing Space Coast rental investments? Don't wait to reach out for a free rental analysis from the Bluefin Property Management team.


